Meet The Team

Meet the Rhonda Gustitus Team!

The Rhonda Gustitus Team is a team of highly trained Real Estate professionals committed to providing an exceptional experience. Led by our fearless leaders Rhonda & Tony Gustitus. Rhonda started out on her own over 25 years ago and very quickly established herself as the go-to realtor in the area. Shortly after that she recruited her husband Tony and the team took off from there! Throughout the years The Rhonda Gustitus Team has helped thousands of families achieve their real estate goals. Everyone has their own unique story and we love getting to know each and every one. This way we learn the best way to we can help our customers and tailor their experience to match their needs. Whether you are looking to buy a home, sell a home, or begin growing your wealth through investing in real estate, we are here to help you every step of the way! If you aren’t sure where to start please give us a call and we will help you get on your way in no time! If you are an experienced investor we would love to help you grow your portfolio.

The Rhonda Gustitus Team is always in the top 1% of their local real estate board and helps hundreds of families every year! We know how important it is to be involved and give back in our local community. We are involved in many local organizations and of course our local Chambers of Commerce. We know that together everyone achieves more! We can’t wait to meet you and learn your story! Meet our team below! Real Estate’s a Dream with The Rhonda Gustitus Team!


Rhonda Gustitus

Founder, Real Estate Specialist

Hello, I’m Rhonda Gustitus, formerly of Milford CT.  I have a terrific story to tell of how I settled here in sunny South West Florida with my wonderful family and started my 25 year career of being a Realtor!  My husband Tony and I decided to get away from the cold weather and take a vacation to Florida. We took along my fun loving mother Rose Marie, and my Grandmother Elvira.   When we arrived in Florida we rented a minivan and traveled down the East Coast and up the West coast, visiting all the tourist attractions and breath taking beaches.  We absolutely fell in love with the West coast of Florida as it reminded me of home.  Very family oriented! We knew then we wanted to move to Florida! We began researching jobs, schools & general statistics of the area and really were impressed at what we found.  Schools in Sarasota & Charlotte Counties were among the best in the state.  Honestly, this was one of our main concerns being blessed with 3 incredible children, we wanted to make sure they received the best education possible.  I quickly began my career as a Realtor and absolutely fell in love with the idea of helping people buy & sell real estate.   It occurred to me that it wasn’t  just a job, it became my passion to listen to my customers’ needs and to provide them with all the information they needed to make them feel comfortable and confident in their real estate decisions! When my customers are happy, I’m happy! Presently 80% of my business is from receiving referrals from my amazing customers of whom I have already had the great pleasure of working with.  I am proud to say, I have the best Real Estate Team in South West Florida! Feel free to call me anytime if you would like to know more about this incredible area we live in.  My team specializes in Sarasota & Charlotte County.  If you ask me, the “best place to live” in South west Florida!  I look forward to meeting you!


Tony Gustitus

Commercial & Residential Real Estate Specialist

Hi I’m Tony Gustitus, I am originally from Bridgeport Connecticut. After graduating college, I moved to Milford Connecticut. I owned two businesses in Milford and worked for the largest wine & beverage distributor in the state. I moved to Florida over 20 years ago with my lovely wife Rhonda and our three children. I immediately joined John Hancock as a financial & estate planner for a few years. I then decided to join my wife and become a licensed realtor. Shortly after, I received my real estate brokers designation. Working every day in this rewarding industry, helping individuals and families find their dream home, business, or satisfy their investment needs is what I live for! I am looking forward to helping you and your family with all of your real estate needs.



Alisha Gustitus-Colligan

Team Manager/Real Estate Specialist

Hi, I’m Alisha Colligan, a Realtor and Team Manager on the Rhonda Gustitus Team. What drew me to the real estate industry is the fact we get to change lives everyday by helping families with their real estate dreams. Everyone is different and has their own story and their own needs, I love that our team gets to learn these stories and help them get to their next chapter in life.

A little about me… I have a bachelor’s degree in marketing from The University of Central Florida. I lived in Miami for three years where I attended Florida International University before transferring up to Orlando to finish my degree at the University Of Central Florida. My last semester of college I was offered a position in a Marketing & Advertising company and soon worked my way up to Office Manager & Production Coordinator. I worked with that company for over 6 years learning the ins and outs of print and online advertising as well as what it takes to manage a company. I was ready for a change and after talking extensively with my parents about their team and all the success they have had helping people in the real estate industry I decided it was time to make another move. I soon joined their team as an Office Administrator, learning their systems and keys to success while taking the necessary real estate courses to get my own license. Now I am able to apply all of my knowledge and experience to continue to help improve our systems and help our team grow. We are always looking for top talent, have an amazing marketing plan, and most importantly helping people achieve all of their real estate goals. Please call us so we can help make your real estate dreams come true!


John Colligan

Real Estate Specialist/ Closing Manager

Hi I’m John, I want you to know I put my all into helping all our clients reach their goals. A little about me… I am married to Alisha Colligan (The Rhonda Gustitus Team Manager) and couldn’t be happier. We have a golden doodle named Sadie who is just like our child. I am a true Floridian, born and raised in Sarasota County. If you are looking for local knowledge you have come to the right place! My Parents have always been very involved with the city my Mom was a dispatcher for the North Port Police Department and my Dad is recently retired from working for the City of North Port. I am a Veteran from the Air force, Security Forces. I was stationed in Anchorage, Alaska and had the chance to travel around the world from Afghanistan to Abu Dhabi. I really enjoy helping other Veterans find the right home to fit their needs. I am a hard worker and will do everything I can to get you the best home for the best price. I look forward to getting to know you!


Tamara Fagan

Closing Manager/Licensed Assistant

Hi I’m Tamara the Closing Manager for the Rhonda Gustitus Team. I help with making sure our closings are smooth and close on time for the Team. I have always been in the customer service industry and the transition into Real Estate has been a pleasant change. I recently bought a home in the area (Thanks RGT!) and seeing first hand what it takes to get a home bought and sold has enhanced my outlook on how to better assist our customers! I am also a licensed Realtor and get to use my expertise to ensure you have the best experience possible! My family & I love the area and I look forward to assisting you with your next real estate goal!



Mayte Romero

Listing Manager

Hello, my name is Mayte Romero and I am the Listing Manager for the Rhonda Gustitus Team. I was born and raised in Peru. I moved to the United States 13 years ago with my parents and only sister. I speak and write both Spanish & English fluently, which allows me to assist any Spanish speaking client throughout the entire selling process. In 2014, I graduated with a Bachelor’s degree in Psychology and a certificate in Behavioral Forensics. I graduated with a Master’s degree in Forensic Psychology from Argosy University. I love working with The Rhonda Gustitus Team. Helping our sellers have a smooth and stress free experience is our main goal. Our entire team is here for you to make the process of selling your home as pleasant as possible!





Eric Gustitus

Buyer Specialist

Hi I’m Eric, a Buyers Specialist on the Rhonda Gustitus Team! I’m 100% committed to listening for exactly what you want and help you find the right home. A little about me …I was born in Bridgeport CT. I have a son, little Eric that is not so little anymore. He goes to North Port High School where I enjoy watching him participate in football, wrestling, and chorus. For activities I like fishing, lifting, sports, meeting new people, and dining out. I worked in the customer service industry for over 15 years. I pursued a firefighting career and transitioned working full time in Emergency Medical Services. I was promoted to field training officer for an ambulance company where I trained new EMT’s in emergent and non-emergent situations. I was promoted the following year to safety officer where I evaluated safety concerns for our employees, patients, working conditions and buildings. My love in life is serving the people in our community. That is why I joined the Rhonda Gustitus Team at Keller Williams. A team that is dedicated to serving our customers and the community. I can’t wait to meet you!



Connie Bennett

Buyer Specialist

Hello, my name is Connie Bennett, a Buyer’s Specialist for the Rhonda Gustitus Team at Keller Williams Realty. A little about me, I grew up in Bradenton, FL and they are still some of my best memories. I got married and moved to West Virginia, where my husband and I were successful real estate investors for 28 years. (It’s never too early or too late to start investing) Moving back to Florida, I wanted to help others, and with my personal Real Estate knowledge putting that to good use was a natural choice. Having bought and sold homes and businesses, I wanted to help others find their dream homes and educate them on investing in real estate.

Joining the Rhonda Gustitus Team was my best decision. We have over 25 years in real estate experience, always putting our customer’s needs first and pride ourselves on 5-star service to every customer. Seeing how hard we work to go above and beyond for our customers because we genuinely care about people and our community, has been an excellent fit for me. I am proud to say I am part of a top producing team that truly cares.


John Bennett

Real Estate Specialist

Hi I’m John, a Buyer and Listing Consultant for the Rhonda Gustitus Team. A little bit about me, I was born and raised in West Virginia. My family are successful real estate investors and that’s where I got my interest in real estate. At a young age I realized how important investing in real estate can be and how it impacts so many lives in a positive way. Being in sales most of my life it was an easy transition into real estate. Now I get to help families everyday increase their wealth through real estate, whether it’s their first home or their tenth! I also have a dog, who has become part of my family, he is a puggle named Bellamy. I am hard working and my focus is always on customer satisfaction. I like to take the consultative approach, learning more about you and your needs to find you the right home. I am excited to get to know you!



Lori Hilding

Buyer Specialist

Hi I’m Lori, Buyer’s Specialist for the Rhonda Gustitus Team. I have been in real estate for over 20 years and know how to find the best deals at the best prices. I have specialized in New Homes and Condominiums successfully helping hundreds of families in a variety of communities. I was honored with the title “Best of the Best” from a previous brokerage. My extensive background in sales and customer relations works hand-in-hand with my commitment to an exceptional customer experience, ensuring the right property solutions for each and every one of my clients. A little about me, I was born and raised in Connecticut. I love life on Florida’s Gulf Coast and am proud to have raised my son here in Sarasota County. Outside of real estate, I love the beach, enjoy an active lifestyle, and frequently attend the theatre, opera and ballet. When you are ready to find your next home, I am here and ready to assist you!